Direct water heaters heat water directly while indirect heaters use a secondary heat source. Direct heaters tend to heat water faster but lose some efficiency. Indirect systems are more complex but maximize efficiency. Consider cost, maintenance, and your needs when choosing.
Choosing the right hot water systems is an important decision when installing or upgrading your hot water supply in a home or business. With two prominent choices at the forefront, direct and indirect systems, discerning which system best heats water for your needs is paramount.
Direct-fired heaters heat water within the unit itself before dispensing it to your taps. As water passes through the heater, it comes into direct contact with a heat source, such as warm air, usually gas burners or heating elements. Tankless and storage tank heaters can both utilise direct heating.
Indirect fired heaters rely on an external heat source, like a furnace or boiler, to warm the water to the ideal temperature. This external heating unit, like a boiler or furnace, heats a transfer fluid that then circulates through a heat exchanger in the heater your indirect system can utilise. The heat exchanger conducts the transfer of warmth effectively to supply temperate water while preventing direct interaction between the fluids in your indirect water heater.
Understanding the differences between direct and indirect water heaters is crucial for evaluating their benefits and drawbacks. Key factors to consider are efficiency, cost, space requirements, ease of installation and suitability for different applications.
Understanding how these systems operate and the advantages of indirect systems can more effectively fulfil the specific needs of your household.
Direct fired heaters operate by heating your water on the spot within the appliance, which differs from indirect models, before directing it to your taps. The primary heat source, which can be gas, oil, or electric elements, is essential for reaching the desired water temperature.
In a tankless coil water heater system, cold inlet water flows into the unit where it comes into direct contact with the burners or heating elements. This process heats the water instantly, on demand, so there no need for a storage tank exists. The unbroken flow, having journeyed past the heating elements, provides an infinite supply of hot water your fixtures require, devoid of any contact with an open flame.
A storage hot water tank heats a full supply of water instead. The tank is insulated to help minimise heat loss during standby periods.
When you turn on a hot tap, pre-heated water is drawn from the tank’s upper region straight to the outlets. Meanwhile, cold tap water infiltrates the lower section of the tank, safeguarding a steady hot water supply for the indirect system water.
Rather than self-contained heating, Indirect water heaters use an external heat source, typically a furnace or boiler, to heat the water in the associated storage tank.
Scorching coolant from your boiler courses through a heat exchanger within the storage tank, primed for the water heater your household uses. This heats the water without allowing direct contact between the fluids. Once heated, the appliance stores water until needed, similar to how your water heater with a direct storage tank sends out hot water.
Indirect systems are generally better aligned with colder climates with a substantial hot water demand, as the water is warmed using residual heat from the home’s primary furnace. This appliance can run with higher efficiency overall. However, these systems tend to be bulkier and require no extra cost compared to direct-fired heaters.
Direct fired heaters operationalise by heating water within the appliance, offering energy savings before supplying the warmed water to your taps. This distinction comes from indirect systems that rely on an ancillary heat source, typically of the gas or electric type water heating.
There are two main types heaters within the direct water heater category:
Opposed to indirect type water heater systems, direct systems are usually more compact, simpler to install, and more suitable for climates with less extreme water demands. These units use hot water only when it’s needed, thereby achieving enhanced efficiency. However they do require an energy source specifically for water heating such as electricity or gas.
Armed with responsive flow control that contemporary water heaters offer and the ability to service multiple demand points simultaneously, they can effortlessly meet the hot water requirements your household presents. They offer a straightforward, low-maintenance solution with fewer parts required, eliminating the need for central heating integration.
Indirect water heaters use an external heat source, rather than heating the water directly. This is usually integrated with the home’s central heating system.
Here’s how they work:
As the water heating is powered through wasted heat from the home’s main space heating system, indirect heaters can achieve very high efficiency. However, they have a larger footprint and higher upfront costs than direct systems.
Indirect heaters are well-suited to colder regions with high hot water demands. They integrate seamlessly into homes with existing hydronic heating systems, providing efficient domestic hot water.
When comparing efficiency and performance between direct and indirect systems, direct heaters generally come out on top in the Australian climate.
Direct systems supply hot water on demand, thus eliminating the need to continuously maintain a volume of stored water. Indirect systems typically rate around 4.5 stars since they require more constant heating in the tank.
This on-demand delivery avoids standby losses and can allow greater energy efficiency. This on-demand delivery avoids standby losses and can allow greater energy efficiency.
Particularly, electric direct systems deliver exceptional adjustment potential, ensuring the heater right meets your necessities for pinnacle efficiency. Smart circulation pumps modulate power based on tap usage. Gas direct heaters can also adjust the burner output to match demand.
While indirect systems recycle waste heat from central heating, the larger storage volume and surface area causes higher heat losses compared to direct options. They may be more suited to very cold regions with greater space heating demands.
For temperate Australian climates with lower hot water usage, the simplicity and efficiency of modern direct heaters makes them the best choice for most homes and light commercial premises.
When it comes to initial costs and installation complexity, indirect water heaters typically require a greater upfront investment than direct systems.
The average cost of installing an indirect system falls between $2,000 and $4,000. This includes the storage tank, heat exchanger, circulation pump, thermostatic mixing valve, associated plumbing and integration with the existing hydronic heating system. Extra costs may be incurred if upgrades are required to the boiler or central heating unit for compatibility.
In contrast, direct heaters have a lower entry price point starting from $600 for basic models. Tankless gas hot water heaters tend to average around $1,500 installed, while their electric storage tank counterparts typically range from $1,000 - $2,000. Direct heaters are less complex to install since they don’t require integration with other systems.
The initial cost greatly depends on the system size needed, with the heater itself being a major influencing factor. Indirect heaters necessitate a sizeable storage tank, capable of servicing more than one home’s anticipated peak demand. Meanwhile direct systems can modulate their heating output, reducing the need for oversized components and tanks.
When substituting an old water heater, indirect systems typically necessitate complete system upgrades to modernise the infrastructure, entailing much more work. Direct heaters can readily replace older models with minimal fuss, highlighting the difference between them and more complex systems, making use of existing electricity and gas connections.
As opposed to systems requiring a boiler furnace, direct water heaters demand relatively minimal maintenance. Tankless models need their burner jets or heating elements descaled annually to prevent mineral buildup which reduces efficiency. The inlet filter should also be attended to—cleaned or replaced, even in spaces without regular maintenance routines—as part of an annual service.
Yearly flushing of the tank water and anode rod replacement every 5 years are necessary for tank models to prevent corrosion. Also drain any sediment annually by flushing the tank.
Indirect water heaters have more involved maintenance needs as they interact with additional systems. The central heating unit and heat exchanger coils need servicing to maintain efficiency. Check for leaks, corrosion, cracks or blockages.
The storage tank itself requires maintenance similar to a direct heater. Drain and flush sediment annually, with anode rod replacement every 5-7 years. Maintain optimal water pressure and temperature.
Routine maintenance is crucial for direct water heaters to ensure optimal efficiency and an extended lifespan. Key maintenance tasks include ensuring operations are efficient than ever:
Adhering to this routine maintenance sidesteps numerous typical issues impacting performance or the lifespan that water heaters offer. Keep maintenance logs and stick to the manufacturers schedule for professional preventative servicing.
Hard water can increase mineral scale buildup requiring more frequent descaling. Using a water softener can help reduce scaling while also benefiting pipework.
With just simple annual tasks, direct water heaters can deliver reliable, efficient service for over 15 years. Proactive maintenance ensures your heater units can provide reassurance that your hot water system won’t fail you.
Indirect water heaters have more involved maintenance requirements than direct systems due to their integration with other heating components.
It’s recommended to service the central boiler or furnace annually in accordance with the manufacturer’s guidelines. The heat exchanger coils inside the storage tank need to be periodically checked for sediment buildup, leaks, corrosion or cracks which can reduce efficiency. Any issues should be addressed promptly by a professional.
The storage tank itself shares similar maintenance needs to a direct water heater. Drain and flush sediment annually by turning off the cold water inlet and opening the drain valve. Every 5-7 years the anode rod should be replaced to protect the tank from corrosion damage.
Indirect system maintenance concentrates on assuring supreme operational efficiency and extended service life, offering their own components consistent upkeep. Keeping detailed maintenance logs also aids any future troubleshooting. Specialist plumbers can best advise on appropriate upkeep for your indirect water heating system setup.
Both direct and indirect water heating systems have environmental impacts from production, operation, and end-of-life disposal to consider.
On the other hand, direct heaters tend to be more efficient than indirect heaters, often having a lower carbon footprint as they heat water only when needed, avoiding standby losses.
However, most run on fossil fuels which contribute greenhouse gas emissions. Electric direct heaters use less renewable energy than gas options. At end-of-life, metal and plastic components can get recycled.
Indirect systems recycle waste heat, but larger storage tanks supplemented by a heat pump lose more ambient heat. At disposal, the integrated system has greater material footprint needing coordination for proper recycling.
The external heating unit often uses natural gas, conducted through hot air. Efficiency optimisations can reduce net emissions.
Ultimately efficient design, renewable energy integration and responsible disposal help minimise environmental impacts for both system types. Solar-assisted heat pumps offer a renewable technology option as an alternative to traditional fuel reliance.
Indirect water heaters are optimal for cold areas with high water usage and pre-existing central heating systems. Indirect water heaters are optimal for cold areas with high water usage and pre-existing central heating systems. Indirect water heaters are optimal for cold areas with high water usage and pre-existing central heating systems. Their simplicity and lower price, achieved through heat efficiency, matches modest demands. Tankless direct heaters conserve space and solar water heating systems offer renewable efficiency benefits. For larger homes, a direct gas storage tank provides ample capacity. For larger homes, a direct gas storage tank provides ample capacity.
If you notice unusual sounds, smells or problems with your gas appliances, it’s important to detect issues early. Check for leaks, faults, carbon monoxide and contact a professional plumber immediately for gas safety checks to keep your home safe.
Read MoreYour hot water system in Gladesville may require a water filter to prevent sediment build-up and calcification which reduces efficiency. High-quality water filtration protects plumbing, enhances water quality and can save on costly repairs.
Read MoreNo, you should never attempt a gas appliance installation yourself. Gas appliances require expert installation by licensed gas fitters to ensure correct and safe connectivity to your gas line, preventing leaks, fire hazards or explosions.
Read MoreGladesville, 2111 NSW
We will call back as soon as possible.
